I ordered this piece because I wanted a fuel door in black for some contrast. This one was inexpensive compared to the rest. It appears to be of good quality in terms of color and gloss. How well it holds up remains to be seen. It did appear to have the slightest of almost imperceptible scratches on its finish. However, as there is an even chance that I did it as opposed to it having been shipped that way, I kept the door and installed it. It looks very good.