I wasn't too sure about this when I ordered it, but once I put it on, (after Dennis Kirk's fast shipping), I really like the way it looks. It does fit pretty tight. I am going to keep trying to work it loose. I like it enough to spend the time to make it fit better. No tails hanging out the back, even though I will order one with tails. I like that it's already formed, so I just throw it on and I'm out the door. My wife likes it and I have received compliments on it. It is made out of sturdy material so it feels like it will last awhile.